Javascript is not enabled.

Javascript must be enabled to use this site. Please enable Javascript in your browser and try again.

We Tried 7 Different Retirement Calculators. Here’s How They Add Up

Your Money

CRUNCH YOUR FUTURE NUMBERS … TODAY

Check out these tools for estimating your retirement income and claiming your Social Security benefits

Illustration of a man and woman walking, behind their shadow is a smart phone on the ground, with a calculator on screen

Search for “retirement calculator” online, and you’ll find links to plenty of tools for answering pressing questions: Will you outlive your money? What’s a realistic retirement budget? What could you get by waiting to claim Social Security?

Although all these tools are designed to address the same general concern—How much money will I have in retirement?they have some big differences. Some will get you quick estimates with little effort. Others can give you more detailed projections if you’re willing to spend more time on them.

We examined more than a dozen free or low-cost calculators available from financial services firms, retirement planning companies and Social Security claiming specialists. Testing with profiles of hypothetical preretirees, we assembled a lineup of calculators worth considering, once we weeded out those with various problems, such as asking for too much personal data.

Even the best tools can’t perfectly predict your future. Each incorporates assumptions about key numbers such as inflation rates, investment returns and your spending needs. (Tellingly, plugging the same information for one test subject into different calculators resulted in monthly income forecasts ranging from $3,470 to $3,880.) All of these assumptions could be wrong, and not every calculator makes it easy to tinker with them.

Still, having an educated guess about your future is better than being completely in the dark. The nonprofit Employee Benefit Research Institute, for example, has found that half of workers who calculated how much they’ll need in retirement started saving more.

Retirement Planning Calculators

AARP

Retirement Calculator

Get an estimate of your savings at retirement age. Also see your year-by-year income forecast—or, if applicable, your income shortfall.
Best Features: The tool works for singles and both married and unmarried couples. Annual income is broken down by source.
Be Aware: Default life expectancy ages are 84 for men and 87 for women. You’ll have to estimate your Social Security income. aarp.org/calculators

BANKRATE

Retirement Calculator

Plug in your current and planned savings to get a quick idea of whether they’ll be sufficient for your desired standard of living.
Best Features: Sliders controlling several variables, such as age of retirement and annual savings, give you instant feedback showing whether, and how quickly, you might run out of money.
Be Aware: Social Security estimates, which can’t be adjusted, are based on out-of-date FICA (Federal Insurance Contributions Act) and benefit numbers, and the calculation assumes that only one spouse in a marriage has earned retirement benefits. bankrate.com/calculators

BOLDIN

Basic Planner

Get answers to questions such as when you can retire, what your income will be and how your net worth will change annually.
Best Features: Ability to handle several complexities other planners don’t, such as the different tax treatments of traditional and Roth IRAs and the effect of claiming Social Security later than your retirement date.
Be Aware: It may take 10 to 20 minutes to set up the planner and a few hours or longer to get the most out of it.
Also Check Out: PlannerPlus ($120/year), which adds many more features, such as precise modeling of Medicare expenses. The Simple Retirement Calculator takes less than a minute to estimate how long your money will last. boldin.com

FIDELITY

Fidelity Retirement Score

Answer six simple questions and see whether your retirement planning is On Target, Good, Fair or Needs Attention.
Best Features: Simplicity and speed
Be Aware: The Retirement Score is just for one person, not a couple.
Also Check Out: Retirement Strategies Tax Estimator, which higher-income taxpayers can use to estimate the tax impact of Roth IRA conversions, charitable giving and retirement savings withdrawals. fidelity.com/calculators

NERDWALLET

Retirement Calculator

Get an estimate of the dollar amount you’ll have upon your expected retirement age, and see how long it will last based on your standard of living.
Best Features: Easy inputs and instant feedback on how changes to your assumptions will affect your financial outcome.
Be Aware: You’ll have to input Social Security income, and you’ll have to figure out for yourself your after-tax retirement income. nerdwallet.com/calculator/retirement-calculator

SCHWAB

Retirement Calculator

Spend a few minutes answering questions about your salary, savings and hoped-for retirement income to get an estimate of how much “extra” savings you’ll have upon retiring or how much you’ll come up short.
Best Features: Clear formats for inputting data and helpful guidance on how to answer questions about your investment style.
Be Aware: The calculator is designed for individuals, not couples; changing inputs doesn’t update results automatically.
Also Check Out: Roth IRA Conversion Calculator, which shows the tax consequences of converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. schwab.com/financial-planning/tools

VANGUARD

Retirement Income Calculator

A fill-in-the-blank tool lets you quickly estimate how much you’ll be able to spend monthly in retirement and how that matches up to your desired spending.
Best Features: Quick answers
Be Aware: There’s not much nuance—no inputs for tax treatment of savings, for example. You have to supply your own benefits estimate for Social Security.
Also Check Out: Retirement Expenses Worksheet, which lets you put in best guesses for retirement spending. investor.vanguard.com/tools-calculators

Richard Eisenberg is a longtime personal finance journalist who contributes to MarketWatch, Fortune and Next Avenue.

Claiming Social Security

The Social Security Administration has numerous calculators on its site to help you estimate the benefits you might receive based on factors such as whether you have a government pension. Find those tools at ssa.gov/benefits/calculators. Here are some other useful Social Security online tools.

AARP

The Social Security calculator provides a quick rough estimate of benefits based on your date of birth and current salary.
Keep in Mind: The tool links to AARP’s free online Social Security resources. aarp.org/calculators

FIDELITY

Based on your date of birth, the Social Security benefit calculator provides your full retirement age (FRA) and estimates your benefit at that age. You can see claiming strategies for you and your spouse, and get claiming strategies if you’re widowed or divorced.
Keep in Mind: As with other calculators able to estimate your benefits, you’ll get more accurate projections and claiming strategies by entering Social Security’s estimate based on your actual earnings history. To get that number, go to ssa.gov/myaccount and set up or access your My Social Security account. fidelity.com/calculators

MAXIMIZE MY SOCIAL SECURITY

This $49/year software package from Boston University economics professor Laurence Kotlikoff runs through more than 1,000 possible claiming strategies, producing a detailed report spotlighting top recommendations for you.
Keep in Mind: You’ll need to put in at least 30 minutes with the program to make full use of it. maximizemysocialsecurity.com

OPEN SOCIAL SECURITY

This free calculator from CPA Mike Piper, author of Social Security Made Simple, displays a color-coded graph showing the desirability of alternate Social Security claiming strategies for you. It can run numbers for you as a couple or as an individual who is widowed, divorced or disabled. It can also estimate your reduction in benefits if the Social Security trust fund is depleted.
Keep in Mind: This is suited for people who aren’t put off by financial jargon such as “present value.” It works best with a Chrome browser. opensocialsecurity.com

T. ROWE PRICE

The brokerage’s easy-to-use Social Security Optimizer works for singles, married couples and people due survivor or divorced spousal benefits. You get a detailed report with Social Security basics and the pros and cons of the claiming strategy calculated to provide your highest lifetime benefits.
Keep in Mind: Plan on spending 30 minutes entering data. The default setting is for a 95-year life expectancy. troweprice.com/socialsecurity

MORE HELP FROM AARP

Find these additional free retirement planning calculators and tools at aarp.org/calculators.

Traditional IRA: See possible growth of retirement savings.

Required Minimum Distribution: Estimate mandatory 401(k) and traditional IRA withdrawals for this year and beyond.

401(k) Savings and Planning: Model your account’s growth based on contributions, employer matches and investment returns.

Self-Employed 401(k) Contributions: See how much you can save in different tax-deferred retirement accounts.

Roth 401(k) vs. Traditional 401(k): Compare estimates of the after-tax value of contributions to these different accounts.

Unlock Access to AARP Members Edition

Join AARP to Continue

Already a Member?

of