Javascript is not enabled.

Javascript must be enabled to use this site. Please enable Javascript in your browser and try again.

Skip to content
Content starts here
CLOSE ×
Search
Leaving AARP.org Website

You are now leaving AARP.org and going to a website that is not operated by AARP. A different privacy policy and terms of service will apply.

The Big Reason I Decided to Have 5 Kids

It used to be the norm, but my husband and I often have our sanity questioned


spinner image writer alexandra frost and her family

“You know how babies are made, right?”

“Are you Catholic?”

“Are they all yours?”

“Did you do that on purpose?”

“Was the fifth your ‘oops’ baby?”

“Good luck with that.”

These are just a few of the responses I get when I tell people I have five kids. Decades ago, this would have been normal. In 1976, almost half of mothers aged from 40 to 44 had four or more children, but for some time now the average has been around two. 

Today, aged 36, I know only one family with as many kids as us and only a handful with four children. So, the comments fly. I’m not offended, because beneath them is a deep curiosity from others. They are wondering, “Why would you want so many kids?”

So, depending on their intention and the exact query, I give them some combination of this: No, I’m not Catholic; Yes, they are mine; Yes, I know how babies are made; No, none of them were an accident; Thanks very much for the good wishes. 

My husband Justin and I are both only children, so we set out to build a family with multiple opportunities for each sibling to have love and support, along with a playmate or two. We’d planned on three to four kids, but after four boys it seemed that one more was still to come. And she was.

Now, on social media, we share moments from our brood’s life as #4frostyboys and #1frostysis. People driving by our yard expect to see multiple Frosties running around like little hooligans anytime the temperature creeps above 36 degrees and I can kick them outside.

spinner image new sign up gif for aec

Subscribe Here!

You can sign up here to AARP Experience Counts, a free email newsletter published twice a month.

Having five kids was the best decision we made. They range in age from nine months to nine years old now. As those well-meaning strangers point out, we do have our hands, and hearts, full now and it’s more than enough — so, no, we aren’t having more.

Here’s why I don’t regret a second of the chaos, the questioning and the decade of becoming a mom again and again (repeat two more times).

Less of a focus on “I”

There are many times each day when my kids must wait. Sometimes they have to figure out something on their own. This is because they are not the only child, there are four others needing my attention and I’m only one person. 

Don’t get me wrong, everyone is fed, clothed, educated, loved and goes on trips for ice cream or a new pair of shoes. But each child individually is not getting what they always want on demand, a culture that is easy to fall into in today’s parenting world. 

With less of a focus on just one person, we are able to cultivate a team mentality as a family, with a group mission.  Some days, the kids are on board with that — others, I’m sure they wish they were only children like we’d wished for big families as kids.

The fine line between fun and chaos

It’s loud in our house — like, really loud. Some people don’t like it, and that’s okay. But my kids are having a whole lot of fun growing up. They always have a friend, they run outside playing football games in the front yard and having a roommate instead of their own room is growing on them. 

Sometimes, there’s a fine line between fun and total chaos. It’s a line we will work to hold every day until they calm down. Which will be never. Until then, we enjoy the rare moments of silence and lean into the crazy, hoping that our kids will grow up remembering it fondly.

We are all being stretched

Parenting five kids, and having many siblings, isn’t always easy or comfortable. It’s a setup that stretches each of the seven of us in different ways. It’s likely why our own parents, aunts and uncles would just shake their heads, somewhat amused, somewhat concerned, each time we announced another pregnancy. My own mother would (half) jokingly say, “If you have any more than this one, I’m NOT watching them.” Which of course was never true.

As parents, my husband and I are increasing our stamina and patience, our appreciation for small wins and just how essential a seriously awesome cup of coffee can be. The kids are being stretched too, to accommodate the vastly different personalities of their siblings, for example. Stretching is hard sometimes, but it’s good for all of us.

And finally…legacy

This is the biggest and most profound reason of all. Like a country song, if I ask myself what I’d leave behind if today was my last day, my immediate thought would be my kids. Having five kids has given me a sense of purpose, meaning and legacy that I could never find through work, travel or even my marriage alone. 

It is a generational, timeless gift, to imagine how they will take their childhood lessons and move out into the world, building their own lives well into the future. At least, that’s what I tell myself when I’m changing my tenth diaper for the day or finding an actual raw potato in the crib.

Unlock Access to AARP Members Edition

Join AARP to Continue

Already a Member?